Fantasy Butt Plugs

Step into a world of wild imagination with our fantasy butt plugs collection. From mystical creature butt plugs to vibrant and otherworldly fantasy anal plugs, these toys are perfect for those who crave playful, adventurous anal exploration. Crafted for comfort, flair, and fantas
Filter

Sort by:
Mystic Egg - Glow in the Dark
Mystic Egg - Glow in the Dark
Sale price$23.98
Hatchling Egg

2 sizes available

Hatchling Egg
Regular price $52.36 Sale priceFrom $28.95
Creature Cocks Eye Of The Spawn Rechargeable Silicone Vibrating and Squirming Butt Plug with Remote - Green
Spawn Gaze Squirm Vibrating Butt Plug
Regular price $59.96 Sale price$39.99
Bang Vibrating Rainbow Butt Plug Silicone Rechargeable - Multicolor
Rainbow Twist Butt Plug
Regular price $39.96 Sale price$24.99
Molten Egg

2 sizes available

Molten Egg
Regular price $29.96 Sale priceFrom $16.95
Creature Cocks Green Eye Silicone Butt Plug - Black/Green - 3 Piece/Set
Emerald Gaze Butt Plug Set
Regular price $29.96 Sale price$19.99
Creature Cocks Red Eye Metal Butt Plug - Black/Metal/Red - 3 Piece/Set
Infernal Gaze Butt Plug Set
Regular price $49.96 Sale price$29.99
Creature Cocks Unicorn Swirl Silicone Butt Plug - Blue/Multicolor/Pink/Purple - Small

3 sizes available

Whimsy Swirl Butt Plug
Regular price $17.96 Sale priceFrom $12.99
Creature Cocks Red Eye Metal Butt Plug - Black/Metal/Red - Small

3 sizes available

Dread Eye Butt Plug
Regular price $14.96 Sale priceFrom $9.99
Creature Cocks Green Eye Silicone Butt Plug - Black/Green - Small

3 sizes available

Cathex Eye Butt Plug
Regular price $11.96 Sale priceFrom $7.99
XL Mystic Egg - Glow in the Dark
XL Mystic Egg - Glow in the Dark
Sale price$47.99
Alien Nation Sprite Silicone Anal Plug - Blue/Pink/Yellow
Dreamweaver Butt Plug
Regular price $39.95 Sale price$21.95
Alien Nation Sprite Jr. Silicone Anal Plug - Blue/Pink/Yellow
Petite Dreamweaver Butt Plug
Regular price $29.95 Sale price$16.95